Tag Archives: Hamdi Salihi

The Letter of the Law

When you’re driving down the highway, minding your own business, cruising at the speed of traffic, would you expect to be pulled over?  You would not.  Tonight, a referee just pulled us over for going 1 mph over the speed limit.

Mark Geiger will say he was following the rules.  He was.  But in soccer, and in life, being consistent is much more important than being strictly right.  Well, unless you’re just a jerk.  Or a cop.

Salihi did indeed encroach in the penalty area on De Rosario’s first penalty, but so did Sheanon Williams.  As Kyle Martino tweeted, if De Ro had missed that, would Geiger have forced a retake?  We’ll never know, but we’ll always know what we think about that.

The red card for Boskovic was another one of those, “Well he DID extend an arm at another player, so…” situations.  He CAN give a red there.  Should he?  No.  A yellow is sufficient.

Dudar’s red card was just stupid.  He has disappointed consistently this season, and I am hoping that his contract for next year is not guaranteed.  His style of play is just not a fit with the team, and his not being in the lineup is not a major problem.  What IS a problem is what his absence does to the rest of the lineup.

Jakovic will slide back in the middle (THANKS BE TO BABY JESUS), but that means we get treated to round 2 of the Mike Chabala show.  The first episode wasn’t very good, so I don’t think we need to see the second one so soon.  Also, Ethan White becomes the only option of the bench in case of injury.  We just got really thin, really fast.

In summary, Mark Geiger will probably sleep just fine tonight.  He will consult his trusty dogeared rule book, read aloud from its text, and enjoy the smell of his own flatulence.  You can be “right” and very wrong all at the same time, and we saw it tonight.

(Edit:  I’ll bet he’s related to Matt Geiger, who is burned into my brain as sucking at basketball.  Fixed, and thanks)

Tagged , , , , , ,

Bon Voyage Boskovic: The Unfortunate Montenegrin

It has been no secret, I have been in favor of the signing of Branko Boskovic, and have been one of the leading advocates of his inclusion in the starting lineup.  I have finally seen the light, and believe that Boskovic is not a fit for United’s style of play, and will be moved on in July when his contract expires.

When Boskovic arrived, no DCU fan had any idea about him, aside from poorly edited Youtube clips and press releases.  Those videos showed a poaching midfielder, and a motivated attacking player; aka exactly what DC was missing at the time.  The player that arrived in DC was not that player.  I have seen a player who I would liken to a less skilled Andrea Pirlo; a deep lying playmaker, looking to play reverse balls and diagonal balls to the wingers.  He does not take the initative to attack center backs and drive toward the goal to create his own shots.  This may be the result of a crisis in confidence, but the team cannot afford to run Boskovic out on the field until he regains his drive.  The current form of Boskovic is like throwing a square tire on a Mustang.  He destroys the shape of the midfield, and does not provide the attacking drive that De Rosario brings to the team.

This is not an indictment of Boskovic as a player.  I think he will be able to go back to Austria, work his way into form, and excel once again.  I just think that his time here is nearing an end, and it will go down as another misidentification of talent by the front office under the Designated Player rule.

The jury is still out on Hamdi Salihi, but some reserve games would do him good, and the MLS Reserve League is too much of a joke to serve the purpose that it provides everywhere else in the world.  Hopefully, I won’t have to write this post for the Albanian in the summer.  But if I do, I already have the alliterative headline ready… “Arrivederci Albanian Asset”.  Needs some work.

Tagged , , ,

Stouffer bringing the noise

Two articles posted by the Washington Examiner’s Craig Stouffer in the past 24 hours deserve to be read by everyone.

The first one talks about what all fans have been saying since Sunday night, “Why the hell are Salihi and Boskovic not starting?”  I said at the time, this looks like a desperate power move.  Craig seems to agree.

While it’s admirable for Olsen to hold both of them to the same obligation that every other player on the team has, to fight and earn their starting jobs each week, Boskovic and Salihi are two of D.C. United’s three highest-earning players. The franchise has made a commitment to each of them. Olsen singled out Boskovic repeatedly as a big reason why D.C. didn’t achieve what it had hoped last season, and from everything Olsen has said during preseason, he played as big a role as he could himself in landing Salihi. Without further explanation from Olsen after last weekend on his lineup change, benching the pair looks like the strong-arm tactic of an inexperienced coach.

The second one just follows up with that, with some questions about whether Olsen is or can provide the type of steadying and calming influence on his players that is necessary.

All I have to say is, Preach.  Olsen made the wrong moves on Sunday, and fans will have to hope that he puts the best 11 players on the field (that are with the team), and lets them work together to figure it out.

Tagged , , ,

Recap: DC United 0, Sporting KC 1

I promised you all that I would get D to do the 6 word recap.  That hasn’t happened.  So, as a head nod to his cleverness, I will be starting the 5 word novel recap.  I can only hope to be half as awesome as my inspiration.

5 Word Novel Recap: Dero- “Who are you guys?”


Leaving RFK, I had the inescapable feeling that I’ve seen this movie before.  The last time I sat in Section 316, I was watching the team capitulate to Chicago Fire in stoppage time, and feeling the urge to drink.  This time, I had to take a breath and realize that this was game 1 of a long season, and that this team has been retooled extensively with little time for coordination.

The best way to impart my feelings on the match are to do ye olde player ratings, instead of writing a journalistic recap, of which you can already find plenty.

Bill Hamid7 (Man of the Match)- I remember last season when many said Hamid was not making the saves he needed to, and that he wasn’t communicating with his back line.  Last night showed the benefit of USMNT callups and an extra year of seasoning.  Hamid was making every save he should, and most of the ones he shouldn’t.  He was communicating with his back line, despite their inability to do as he was instructing them.  More on that soon.

Daniel Woolard- 6 (1st half) 4 (2nd half) 5 average- In the first half, Woolard was being targeted by SKC, and aside from poor distribution and some strange throw in decisions, Woolard was proving adequate.  Not stellar, but not bad.  In the second half, Woolard was targeted less, but when he was called upon, he was unable to keep up his effort.  The goal was partly his fault, but mostly the fault of poor team marking.  This game was Daniel Woolard in a nutshell.

Brandon McDonald- 6  McDonald was the best of a bad to average backline last night.  He was physical, loud, and usually in the right place.  He had to cover for his partner frequently, and was not shy about telling Dejan what he thought of his performance.

Dejan Jakovic- 4 Poor performance from the Canadian, who seemed to be a step behind the entire night.  SKC has a quick and talented front line but Jakovic showed major rust and an inability to fight the speed of the opponent.  At the most important, Jakovic (one of the team’s tallest players) was inexplicably guarding an SKC player outside of the 18.  This proved decisive, and DC wound up walking out of RFK with no points.

Robbie Russell- 5 Not impressed with Russell last night.  Distribution was poor out of the back, and he was largely anonymous for most of the match.  I believe he will improve as the season progresses.

Andy Najar 6- The 6 is perhaps charitable, as despite Najar’s talent and speed, he was unable to provide service for the forwards.  A number of times, Najar refused to get the ball into the box with his left foot, preferring to try to send in a cross with his right despite no openings.  Along with the rest of the team, he showed a lack of understanding of his teammates.

Branko Boskovic 4- This one pains me, as I have been a Branko Booster since he’s gotten here.  To be fair, this is the first real match Branko has paid in about a year.  Unfortunately, that fact was plainly evident.  A number of square balls intercepted by the SKC midfield almost lead to goals, and he offered very little going forward.  He was more committed to defense than he has been in the past, but Branko needs to be better.

Perry Kitchen 5- Kitchen was doing the best he could, and that was pretty darn good.  Did a good job disrupting passing lanes and getting physical when necessary.  His presence will be noticeably missed.

Chris Pontius- 5- The team missed Pontius at the tail end of last season, and they were surely glad he was able to start the opening match of the season.  Not a bad match by Pontius, but like Najar, Chris was unable to provide service to Salihi and DeRo.

Dwayne De Rosario- 5- The 2011 MVP was anonymous, but skillful on the rare occasions he got the ball at his feet in the box.  More minutes with Branko and Salihi are important, and in the next few weeks, De Ro should be back to his old self.

Hamdi Salihi- 5- Salihi had two real opportunities, a lofted header and an odd man rush in the second half that he scuffed wide.  Hard to judge Hamdi on those two chances, especially since he rarely got the ball.  I am excited to see him as the weeks progress and the team gets a better understanding of how to get the ball to him.

Subs: Josh Wolff, Danny Cruz, Maicon Santos- 5 Neither good nor bad.  Only Santos had a chance to contribute, and it didn’t quite work out.  Olsen made the subs most probably would have made, but last night, they were ineffective.

All these numbers aside, patience is key for the DC United fan early this season.  As previously noted, this team has gone through major changes this season, and hasn’t had a chance to play together with the first choice XI.  Further call-ups and tournaments are certain to disrupt this as the season progresses, but as the season continues this offense will gel.  They are too talented not to.

Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , ,
Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 203 other followers